Summer Househas been one of Bravo’s biggest guilty pleasures. Capturing the summer antics in the Hamptons,Summer Housedepicts every hook-up, party, and fight.As the friend group evolves, with faces coming and going, each season ofSummer Househas brought a different dynamic, highlighting how beautiful and how messy friendships can get. As the alcohol flows and the fights explode,Summer Househas risen to the top of the Bravo intellectual properties.
Since 2017,Summer Househas evolved from some fun-seeking twenty and thirty-somethings having the time of their lives to Bravolebrities eager to have their moment. Of the over two dozen castmembersSummer Househas had, some stand out, for better or for worse. Whether they are fun-loving and therefore a good time or the source of high drama, fans have been captivated by the cast season after season.These are the ten best cast members ofSummer Housethroughout its eight seasons.
Summer House
10Lindsay Hubbard
Season 1 - Present
What a roller-coasterLindsay Hubbardhas been on since the first season ofSummer House. One of the most polarizing figures on the show,Lindsay is someone who brings the shock factor season after season.Between tumultuous relationships to her inability to accept she’s ever wrong, Lindsay is what reality television is all about out.Lindsay has been at the forefront of many sound bites, including the meme-worthy, “How many sandwiches have you made for me?” Many of her summers have included toxic relationships, but her relationship in the most recent season has defined exactly who Lindsay is.
Following the breakup withCarl Radkeat the end of Season 8, it’s hard to figure out where Lindsay goes next. There was certainly admiration for the pair, but they were never truly going to work. The moment he questioned his sobriety, it was over. Moving forward, Lindsay has pushed aside so many of her cast mates over the years and for her to return for another season, she might have a lot of groveling to do. Or she’ll just spend the summer causing drama like a great reality star should do. Wherever you stand on Lindsay, love or hate her, she has helped makeSummer Housethe perfect guilty pleasure.
9Carl Radke
Carl Radke’s journey toSummer Housewas quite personal. Coming in as a lady’s man, Carl seemed like he would be a cool presence on the show.As time went on and faces began to change, Carl’s character shifted.He andKyle Cookewere thick as thieves, partying all weekend and working together on Loverboy during the week. Well, how much work Carl was doing would forever be a sticking point.
Through the tragic loss of his brother,Carl revealed his issue with substance abuse, a topic that played a major factor during his time on the show. And then there wasLindsay Hubbard.Some fans were eager to see RadHouse tie the knot, but their close friends, and intuitive fans, knew it was a disaster waiting to happen. With Carl and Lindsay being two of three original cast mates, it would be weird to see one depart, but for the sake of Carl’s mental well-being, it may be time to cut ties with the show that made him a household name.
8Luke Gulbranson
Season 4–6
Luke Gulbransonis a difficult one because he was quite misunderstood. The Minnesota native had ideals that were much different than those of his New York counterparts. He was laid back. Until he wasn’t.When Luke was pushed to the brink, he exploded to scary levels.And that’s where many fans seemed to turn on him.
Luke’s treatment of women was something that was called out by his housemates,which ensued into a brawl that producers had to step in to de-escalate.But he was a loyal person who just wanted to be a good person. It just was never portrayed that way.
7Hannah Berner
Season 3–5
WatchingHannah BerneronSummer Housemight have given you whiplash. One moment, she was a bubbly bright light withPaige DeSorboas her Giggly Squad partner in crime.The next moment, she had a royal downfall that led to her departure from the show. Hannah’s journey on the show was filled with dry humor and jokes that pushed many of her cast mates away.
Which is interesting seeing that, since her departure fromSummer House, she’s been one of the most sought-after stand-up comics. Hannah knew when to call it quits, which might have been for the best for all involved. She’s happily in love with an older man, while her good pals Paige and Amanda Batula have been able to flourish on their own. If you ever run into Hannah,just don’t ever bring up her dad. She might explode on you.
6Andrea Denver
All he wanted to do was have a nice Italian family dinner! Though supermodel and former “Blank Space” music video boyAndrea Denver’s time onSummer Housewas short-lived, he defied the odds of the typical bro persona that had previously filled the share house. Serving as a kind person who happened to be eye candy, Andrea was the opposite of high drama.He just wanted to have a fun summer with his friends! And he wanted to experience true love!
No one has ever had quite a big heart like Andrea Denver. He was a great housemate who truly made his time on the show worthwhile. You loved him for not making drama, which is why he wasn’t right for a reality show at the same time. WhyPaige DeSorbopass up Mr. Perfect will forever be a major question mark!
5Stephen McGhee
Season 1–2
As the only gay cast member to appear as a full time member of the show,Stephen McGeewas part of the original roster onSummer House. Having a very close bond with the Wirkus Circus, aka blonde twinsLauren and Ashley Wirkus, Stephen ultimately didn’t fit the directionSummer Housewas going.
He was often the level-headed one, serving as the voice of reason. While he did occasionally have some run-ins with his fellow housemates, namely revealingCarl Radke’s secret about another guy, Stephen was often drama and conflict-free.Stephen’s time on the show allowed him to share some important queer narrativesincluding, bringing his housemates to New York City Pride, dating in the Hamptons, andhis struggle with being openly gay to his conservative family.Perhaps his lack of high-octane drama caused his untimely departure following Season 3.
4Amanda Batula
Season 2 - Present
WhenSummer Housefans were first introduced toAmanda Batula, they felt bad for her because she had no idea howKyle Cookewas treating her. Never did they expect a summer fling to turn into one of the most celebrated Bravo romances. Amanda has a kind heart and good intentions. She just had some hotheads standing in her way. Her loyalty to Kyle is what dreams are made of, even during the extreme moments of his cheating scandal.
Amanda’s time onSummer Househas very much been an evolution of her relationship whiledivulging some deeply personal struggles with her fertility.Many fans and friends have hoped better for Amanda, but she’s stood strong in her ways. Amanda has tried to make a name for herself apart from being Kyle’s better half and Paige’s bestie.Once she gains her wings to truly soar, Amanda will finally feel like a real star ofSummer Houseand not a supporting player.
3Kyle Cook
How could you not love Mr. Loverboy! Summer House began as a backdoor pilot through a moment onVanderpump Rules. It all started when he comparedStassi SchroedertoSteve Jobsin the hot tub? As one of three original full-time cast mates onSummer House,Kyle Cookeis the epitome of the boy who doesn’t want to grow up. And that’s why we love him! Known for his blossoming romance with his summer fling turned girlfriend turned fiancé turned wife,Amanda Batula, Kyle has shown immense growth as a person over the years.
As the life of the party, Kyle’s mission is to have fun! And if you’re not having fun, he’ll let you know. He might even have a tantrum. Easily the face of the franchise,Kyle epitomizes what a summer in the Hamptons is all about.Though perhaps a new chapter for Kyle and Amanda is ready to be televised, fans can’t imagine a summer without him. But thankfully, that mullet is gone for good!
2Ciara Miller
Season 5 - Present
As the first Black cast member onSummer House,Ciara Millercame in and established her place in the Hamptons. The nurse may have felt some struggles finding her footing as a new member of the friends group, but once she did, she’s since soared. Between being played by many men who have entered the share house to being on the wrong side of some misguided arguments, Ciara consistently deserved better. Which made her become one of the few characters to truly root for and want to see come out the other end as a champion.
Lindsay Hubbardwill always be in the wrong for kissingSouthern Charm’sAusten Krollon her birthday following Ciara’s winter romance.She might always be remembered for her infamous Italian night fight withDanielle Oliveraover an “idiot guy,“but when she wasn’t flinging wine and glasses across the table, Ciara was a cool chick. All those boys truly missed out.
1Paige DeSorbo
Season 3 - Present
Is there anyone sweeter thanPaige DeSorbo? Bringing a perfect balance of fun and authenticity, Paige has risen to the top of the leaderboard because there’s simply nothing you can fault her for. Like many new cast members to joinSummer House, Paige took a bit to establish herself. While some of her castmates weren’t amused by her jokes in her confessionals, others have laughed along with her since she joined the show. The girl just knows how to roast! Now that she’s well insulated as one of the longer-tenured cast members,Paige brings a tell-it-like-it-is personality to the friend group that often needs a dose of reality.
Paige is a “girl’s girl” and has pretty much gotten along with all the girls, with the major exception of Lindsay Hubbard. But that’s because Lindsay sees Paige as a threat to her status as the Queen Bee. With her romance withSouthern CharmstarCraig Conovercontinuing to grow,perhaps Paige will be the next one to get engaged.Until then, Paige continues to dazzle as a superstar.
